NYC Intro 518 Explained: Will Amazon Really Add $5 Per Order?
Amazon says NYC's Delivery Protection Act (Intro 518) could add up to $5 per order. What the bill does, who backs it, and when it could pass.

Amazon is now telling New York City customers that a City Council bill, Intro 518 (the "Delivery Protection Act"), "could add up to $5 per order" if it passes. The bill would require last-mile delivery warehouses in the city to get a city licence and, according to its sponsor and press coverage, would stop companies like Amazon from using subcontracted delivery firms. As of 19 November 2026 it has not been voted on. It is "Laid Over in Committee" after an April hearing, even though 34 Council Members have signed on as sponsors.
That $5 figure is Amazon's own estimate. No independent study we could find calculates a per-order number. Below we explain what the bill says, where each number comes from, who supports and opposes it, and what NYC shoppers can expect next.
What is Intro 518, the NYC Delivery Protection Act?
Intro 518 (file number Int 0518-2026) is a proposed local law titled "Requiring the licensing of last-mile facilities". The official NYC Council legislation record summarises it like this: operators of certain warehouses and storage facilities that deliver goods to final consumers in the city would need a business licence from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP). The licence would come with safety, training and employment conditions, and the bill sets out enforcement options for both the city and workers.
The part that matters most to Amazon is the employment condition. According to Supply Chain Dive, the bill would require operators of last-mile facilities to directly employ core delivery and warehouse workers instead of contracting that work out, with a two-year grace period to comply. The Teamsters, who back the bill, describe it as banning subcontracting for last-mile delivery drivers in the five boroughs.
Amazon delivers much of its NYC volume through Delivery Service Partners (DSPs). These are independent small businesses that hire the drivers who wear Amazon vests and drive Amazon-branded vans. In its April testimony, Amazon said the bill would prohibit its agreements with more than 40 local DSPs that employ more than 5,000 people.
Intro 518 at a glance
| Item | What we know | Source |
|---|---|---|
| File number | Int 0518-2026 | NYC Council Legistar |
| Prime sponsor | Council Member Tiffany L. Cabán | NYC Council Legistar |
| Introduced | 12 February 2026 | NYC Council Legistar |
| Council Member sponsors | 34 of 51, plus the Public Advocate and two borough presidents | NYC Council Legistar |
| Committee | Consumer and Worker Protection | NYC Council Legistar |
| Hearing | 9 April 2026; laid over the same day | NYC Council Legistar |
| Current status | Laid Over in Committee (no vote scheduled that we could find) | NYC Council Legistar, Streetsblog NYC |
| Mayor's position | Supports it (Mayor Zohran Mamdani) | Fox Business, Teamsters |
| Amazon's claim | "Could add up to $5 per order" | About Amazon, 19 Nov 2026 |
How much would Intro 518 add to an Amazon order?
Amazon's customer message, published 19 November 2026, says the Council bill "could add up to $5 per order". It does not explain how that number was calculated or whether it would show up as a fee, a higher item price, or a higher free-shipping threshold.
There are three different numbers going around, and they come from different places:
| Figure | What it claims | Who produced it | How to read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Up to $5 per order | Extra cost per NYC order | Amazon (customer message, Nov 2026) | Amazon's own estimate; no method published |
| $664 per household per year | Extra delivery costs passed to each NYC household | AKRF analysis commissioned by the Five Borough Jobs Campaign, as cited by Amazon to Fox Business | Modelled scenario where carriers relocate out of the city |
| 267% higher cost per package | For deliveries now handled by NYC facilities | Same AKRF analysis, per Fox Business | Under "full relocation" modelling only |
Supply Chain Dive, which reviewed the June 2026 AKRF report, says about 36% of NYC's daily parcel volume is tied to contractor operations at risk from the bill, and that the report expects same-day and next-day services "would likely be curtailed" if carriers move work to places like New Jersey.
There's also an older comparison that opponents point to. Chamber of Progress, a tech-industry group that opposes the bill, cites DCWP data showing the average consumer fee on NYC restaurant delivery orders rose from $4.05 in Q1 2022 to $6.97 in Q1 2025 after the city's delivery-worker minimum pay rule. That is a different industry and a different law, so it shows how costs can be passed on, not what Intro 518 would cost.
Bottom line on price: every dollar figure in this debate comes from Amazon or from groups on one side of it. Nobody has published a neutral per-order estimate. Treat "$5" as an upper-end warning from an interested party, not a confirmed fee.
Why is Amazon against the Delivery Protection Act?
Amazon's arguments, from its testimony and its new customer message:
- DSPs would be shut out. Amazon says the bill would end its contracts with 40+ local DSPs and put 5,000+ jobs at risk. It says about 25% of its NYC DSPs are owned by Black or Hispanic entrepreneurs and 10% are veteran-owned.
- Delivery could move out of the city. Amazon says it would have to consider "relocating operations and delivery facilities outside of New York City", which it says would mean "slower and more expensive delivery for millions of customers."
- Penalties could pile up. Amazon told the committee that minor administrative errors, such as incomplete training paperwork, could add up to shutdowns under the licensing system.
- Pay is already above the minimum. Amazon says NYC DSP drivers have averaged nearly $24 an hour since January 2025. That is Amazon's figure; we could not check it independently.
Amazon has also said it is "not looking to leave New York City" (per Fox Business) and has invited every Council Member to visit its delivery stations before voting.
Why do supporters want it?
The bill's backers, including the Teamsters, Mayor Mamdani and Council Member Cabán, argue the DSP model lets Amazon control drivers' routes, quotas and hiring standards without being their legal employer. Mamdani's office said subcontracting lets corporations set productivity quotas "while denying workers are employees" (as reported by Fox Business).
Recent events have sharpened the fight. Streetsblog NYC reported that about 200 workers at Kaizen Management Solutions, a DSP doing same-day deliveries for Amazon, were let go effective 18 November. Council Speaker Julie Menin called the firings "terrible" and said the city would regulate Amazon "in a very significant way." Amazon told Streetsblog it ended the contract after an investigation found the DSP put e-cargo bikes back on the road before repairs and committed contract breaches including failing to accurately record drivers' hours.
The Teamsters also claim Amazon has spent more than $8 million campaigning against the bill. That is the union's figure and we have not verified it.
When will NYC vote on Intro 518?
There is no scheduled vote that we could find. The bill has to pass the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection before the full Council can vote. Streetsblog reports that Speaker Menin is still working through what she calls "legal issues", and a spokesperson said she is committed to passing it, without a timeline.
Timeline: how we got here
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 12 Feb 2026 | Intro 518 introduced by Council Member Cabán and referred to committee |
| 8 Apr 2026 | Amazon publishes written testimony opposing the bill |
| 9 Apr 2026 | Committee hearing held; bill laid over |
| Jun 2026 | AKRF cost report prepared for the Five Borough Jobs Campaign (per Supply Chain Dive) |
| Aug 2026 | Mayor Mamdani voices support (per Supply Chain Dive) |
| 22 Oct 2026 | Teamsters rally at City Hall demanding a vote |
| 12 Nov 2026 | Speaker Menin calls DSP layoffs "terrible" at a press conference (per Streetsblog) |
| 18 Nov 2026 | Kaizen DSP layoffs take effect (per Streetsblog) |
| 19 Nov 2026 | Amazon tells NYC customers the bill "could add up to $5 per order" |
What are drivers and New Yorkers saying?
We could not access Reddit directly for this story, so here are reactions that were published and attributed by the press:
- For the bill: Matthew Multari, who has delivered for a DSP in Woodside, Queens, told NY1: "Amazon's been squeezing out the DSPs." He argued direct employment could improve pay, benefits and route pace. Queens van driver LeAnn Rivera told Streetsblog she supports the bill for job security.
- Against the bill: Charles DiMaria, who owns a Lower Manhattan bike-delivery company with 150 employees, told NY1: "What this bill does for me is actually close and shut down my business." Grigor Puleri, owner of Puleri Logistics, said there is "no level of certainty" that displaced workers would be rehired.
The questions readers are searching for most are simple ones: Is the $5 fee real? Has the bill passed? Will Prime still be free in NYC? Short answers: the fee is a projection, the bill has not passed, and Amazon has not announced any change to Prime pricing in New York.
What should NYC Amazon customers do now?
- Don't expect a new fee yet. Nothing changes unless the bill passes committee, passes the full Council and becomes law. Even then, Supply Chain Dive reports a two-year grace period for the direct-employment rule.
- Check your checkout page, not headlines. If Amazon ever adds a city-specific charge, it would show up in the order summary before you pay.
- Have a say if you want one. Amazon is asking customers to contact their Council Member. Supporters are doing the same. You can find your member on the NYC Council website.
- Use pickup options during the holidays. Pickup points and lockers are unaffected by this debate, and they're a useful backup in December. For holiday timing, see our guide to Amazon's holiday return policy.
Editor's take
This is a lobbying fight being run partly through customers' inboxes, and both sides are using numbers that suit them. Amazon's "$5 per order" has no published method behind it. The Teamsters' "$8 million" is also unverified. The facts that are on the public record are that the bill has a supermajority of sponsors, a mayor who backs it, and a Speaker who still hasn't brought it to a vote. That means the most likely result is a compromise, not the bill as written. A longer phase-in, carve-outs for small operators, or changes to the licensing penalties all seem possible. If you shop on Amazon in NYC, nothing changes this holiday season. The real test is whether a negotiated version keeps same-day and next-day delivery inside the five boroughs.
For context on how Amazon is handling delivery elsewhere, see its first Puerto Rico delivery station in Dorado, which runs on the same DSP model at issue in New York. It also follows the Unifor contract at Amazon's YVR2 site in Canada. Amazon is hiring for the season too; see Amazon's 2026 holiday hiring.
FAQ
What is Intro 518 in NYC?
Intro 518 (Int 0518-2026) is a New York City Council bill that would require last-mile delivery warehouses to get a city licence with safety, training and employment conditions. Supporters call it the Delivery Protection Act.
Has the Delivery Protection Act passed?
No. As of 19 November 2026, the NYC Council record shows it "Laid Over in Committee" after a 9 April hearing. No vote has been scheduled publicly.
Will Amazon charge $5 per order in NYC?
Not now. Amazon says the bill "could add up to $5 per order" if it passes. That is Amazon's estimate, and no fee exists today.
Who is sponsoring the Delivery Protection Act?
Council Member Tiffany Cabán is the prime sponsor. The Council record lists 34 Council Members in total as sponsors, plus Public Advocate Jumaane Williams and the Brooklyn and Manhattan borough presidents.
Would Amazon leave New York City?
Amazon says it would have to consider moving delivery operations outside the city if the bill passes. It has also said it is "not looking to leave New York City."
Does Intro 518 affect UPS and FedEx?
It applies to last-mile facility operators in general. Supply Chain Dive reports FedEx, which also uses contractors, opposes it. UPS already employs its own drivers and is seen as less affected.
What is an Amazon DSP?
A Delivery Service Partner is an independent company that employs drivers to deliver Amazon packages under contract. Amazon says it works with more than 40 in NYC.
When is the Intro 518 vote?
There is no date yet. The committee has to approve it before the full Council can vote. Speaker Julie Menin's office says she is still working through legal issues.
Sources
- NYC Council Legistar, Int 0518-2026: https://legistar.council.nyc.gov/LegislationDetail.aspx?ID=7879110&GUID=BDDD32F1-1178-492D-80F2-205845356FD2
- About Amazon, "A message from Amazon to customers about New York City delivery costs" (19 Nov 2026): https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/policy-news-views/amazon-new-york-city-delivery-protection-act-costs
- About Amazon, Amazon's testimony on the proposed Delivery Protection Act (8 Apr 2026): https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/policy-news-views/amazon-testimony-delivery-protection-act-new-york-city
- Streetsblog NYC, "Council Speaker Slams Amazon For Delivery Worker Layoffs" (13 Nov 2026): https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2026/11/13/council-speaker-slams-amazon-for-delivery-worker-layoffs
- Supply Chain Dive, "How a New York City bill could shake up Amazon, FedEx delivery operations" (27 Aug 2026): https://www.supplychaindive.com/news/how-a-new-york-city-bill-could-shake-up-amazon-fedex-delivery-operations/828860/
- Fox Business, "Amazon warns Mamdani-backed delivery mandate could cost NYC households hundreds every year" (2 Sep 2026): https://www.foxbusiness.com/retail/amazon-warns-mamdani-backed-delivery-mandate-could-cost-nyc-households-hundreds-every-year
- NY1, "City Council bill could force Amazon to hire contracted delivery workers" (10 Apr 2026): https://ny1.com/nyc/all-boroughs/politics/2026/04/10/city-council-bill-could-force-amazon-to-hire-contracted-delivery-workers
- Teamsters, "Teamsters Rally for Delivery Protection Act at New York City Hall" (22 Oct 2026): https://teamster.org/2026/10/teamsters-rally-for-delivery-protection-act-at-new-york-city-hall/
- Chamber of Progress, "No Free Shipping: What NYC's Amazon Delivery Bill Would Cost New Yorkers" (13 May 2026): https://progresschamber.org/insights/nyc-amazon-delivery-bill-intro-518-cost-new-yorkers/
Featured image: An Amazon Prime delivery van in Hillcrest, Queens, New York City (2019), photo by Tdorante10 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Source